When independent reviewers take a hard look at dog food, they typically focus on four things:
- Ingredient quality
- Nutritional value
- Digestibility and safety
- Whether dogs actually thrive on it
That’s why it was meaningful for Dogster to give Jiminy’s a 4.8/5 rating in their review of our dog food.
Unlike many “eco-friendly” products that compromise on nutrition, the review recognized something central to Jiminy’s philosophy: sustainability only matters if the food genuinely helps dogs thrive.
WHAT STOOD OUT IN THE REVIEW
HIGH-QUALITY NOVEL PROTEIN
Jiminy’s uses insect protein — primarily cricket protein and black soldier fly larvae protein — as the foundation of its recipes.
That matters because insect protein is:
- Highly digestible
- Rich in essential amino acids
- Naturally hypoallergenic for many dogs
- More sustainable than traditional livestock proteins
For dogs struggling with food sensitivities, itchy skin, chronic loose stool, or digestive upset, novel proteins can make a significant difference.
GREAT FOR DOGS WITH SENSITIVITIES
One recurring theme in customer feedback is that many dogs do better on Jiminy’s after struggling with traditional proteins like chicken, beef, or lamb.
Because most dogs have never been exposed to insect protein before, it can work well for dogs with suspected food sensitivities or chronic gut issues.
Pet parents frequently report improvements in:
- Stool quality
- Gas
- Itching and licking
- Coat quality
- Overall digestion
STRONG INGREDIENT QUALITY
The Dogster review also highlighted the ingredient profile and formulation quality.
Jiminy’s recipes avoid many common fillers while incorporating functional ingredients designed to support:
- Gut health
- Skin and coat health
- Digestive health
- Overall wellness
The goal was never to create a gimmick product. The goal was to build a nutritionally complete food that solves real problems for dogs.
DOGS ACTUALLY LOVE IT
One challenge with any new protein source is palatability.
A sustainable dog food that dogs refuse to eat is not a viable product.
Fortunately, this has consistently been one of Jiminy’s strengths. Many customers describe their dogs as unusually excited about the food and treats — particularly the cricket-based recipes.
WHY THIS MATTERS
Independent reviews matter because consumers are understandably skeptical.
There are thousands of dog foods making big claims. Third-party evaluations help separate marketing from actual product quality.
A strong rating from a long-standing pet publication like Dogster reinforces what many Jiminy’s customers already report: dogs can do extremely well on insect protein diets.
And importantly, the environmental benefits come without sacrificing nutrition or performance.
READ THE FULL DOGSTER REVIEW
You can read the complete review here:
Jiminy’s Dog Food Review on Dogster
FAQS
IS JIMINY’S REALLY GOOD FOR DOGS WITH ALLERGIES OR SENSITIVE STOMACHS?
For many dogs, yes.
Jiminy’s uses insect protein as a novel protein source, which can be helpful for dogs reacting to more common proteins like chicken or beef. Many customers report improvements in loose stool, gas, itching, paw licking, and skin irritation after switching.
As always, individual dogs vary, and pet parents should work with their veterinarian for severe or persistent symptoms.
WHY IS INSECT PROTEIN CONSIDERED HIGH QUALITY?
Insect protein contains all essential amino acids dogs need and is highly digestible.
Research has also shown that insect protein may support gut health and skin health while offering a dramatically lower environmental footprint than traditional livestock proteins.
DID DOGSTER REALLY GIVE JIMINY’S A 4.8/5 RATING?
Yes. Dogster’s review of Jiminy’s Dog Food gave the food a 4.8 out of 5 rating.
HAVE OTHER INDEPENDENT REVIEWERS REACHED SIMILAR CONCLUSIONS?
Yes. Multiple independent publications and review platforms have highlighted both the nutritional quality and sustainability benefits of Jiminy’s.
WHAT OTHER USERS ARE SAYING
- Forbes — Rated Jiminy’s among the best sustainable dog foods and noted the combination of quality and eco-friendliness.
- The Strategist — Famously wrote: “My dog loves these cricket protein treats more than she loves me!”
- Amazon — Customer reviews frequently mention improvements in digestion, allergies, stool quality, and enthusiasm at mealtime.
IS JIMINY’S ONLY ABOUT SUSTAINABILITY?
No — and this is an important distinction.
Sustainability may attract people initially, but most customers stay because they see health improvements in their dogs. The nutrition and functionality of the food comes first. The environmental benefits are an additional advantage.
